top of page


Exploring Bay Shore

Things to do in and around Bay Shore

Boulton Center for the Performing Arts- 631-969-1101- 37 W Main Street Bay ShoreNY 11706

Gardiner County Park- 631-854-4949- Montauk Highway Bay Shore NY 11706

Sagtikos Manor- 631-854-0939- Montauk Highway and Manor Lane Bay Shore NY 11706

Drew Patrick Spa-631-206-3739 128 W Main Street Bay Shore NY 11706

Bay Shore Mini Golf- 631-665-2400- 500 East Main St. Bay Shore NY 11706

Fire Island National Seashore- 21 Communities accessible by the Fire Island Ferry, Fire Island Water Taxi or private boat- See below for complete listing.

Fire Island Lighthouse

LI Jr. Ducks Baseball Camp- 631-665-2267- 41 Saxon Ave Bay Shore NY 11706

High Velocity Indoor Paintball- 631-242-2096- 235 S. Fehr Way Bay Shore NY 11706

Great Bay YMCA- 631-665-4255- 200 West Main Street Bay Shore NY 11706

Great South Bay Brewery- 631-392-8472- 25 Drexel Drive Bay Shore NY 11706

Heartland Golf Park- Short 15 minute drive from the marina- 631-352-2595 -1 Executive Drive Edgewood NY 11717

Main Street Shopping- located within walking distance from the marina (.4 miles) quaint shops and restaurants (listed below) such as, Willy Nilly Trading

Company, Ralphs Italian Ices, Ralph & Maria’s Pork Store, Drew Patrick Spa.

South Shore Mall- 631-665-8600 1701 Sunrise Highway Bay Shore NY 11706

Bayard Cutting Arboretum- 15 minute drive from the marina- 631-581-1002- 440 Montauk Highway Great River NY 11739

Hecksher State Park- 631-581-2100. Located in East Islip. Boat ramp available

Where to eat in the town of Bay Shore

The Lake House- American, 135 Maple Ave 631-666-0995**

Tula Kitchen-Vegan/American,41 E Main St 631-539-7183

AJI 53- Sushi/Japanese, 53 E Main St 631-591-3107

Tullulahs- American, 10 4th Ave631-969-9800

Fat Fish- Seafood, 28 Cottage Ave. 631-666-2899 **

Salt & Barrel-Seafood/American, 61 W Main St631-647-8818

Nicky’s Clam Bar- Seafood, 99 Maple Ave 631-665-6621

Salvatores- Pizza/Italian, 120 E Main St 631-206-1060

Chowder Bar- Seafood, 123 Maple Ave 631-665-9859

Local Burger Co- Burgers, 62 E Main St, 631-647-8300

Verde Kitchen & Cocktails – Mexican, 70 E Main St 631-665-6300

Aria Melanie on the Lake – Mediterranean 240 W Main St631-500-9045

Changing Times Sport Bar- American, 29 E Main St 631-647-7871

Bagel Boss Café- Breakfast, 555 E Main St 631-665-9820

New Forum Diner- Breakfast, 315 E Main St 631-666-4455

Nicky’s on the Bay- American, 150 S Clinton Ave 631-206-3311**

Captain Bills- American, 122 Ocean Ave. 631-665-6262 **

Accessible by boat

Where to dock on Fire Island

Watch Hill Marina- National Park Service 631-597-3109

Ocean Beach Marina- 631-583-5153

Davis Park Marina-631-597-9090

Atlantique- Must be Islip Resident- 631-583-8610

Sailors Haven- National Park Service

Where to eat on Fire Island

Surfs Out-Seafood/Italian, 1 Bay Walk Kismet631-583-7400**

The Kismet Inn-American, 1 Oak St Kismet 631-583-5592**

Le Dock- Seafood/French/American, 60 Bay Walk Fair Harbor 631-583-5200**

Matthews- Seafood, 935 Bay Walk Ocean Beach631-583-8016 **

Flynn’s- Seafood/American, 1 Cayuga St Ocean Beach 631-583-5000 **

Island Mermaid-American, 780 Bay Walk Ocean Beach 631-583-8088**

Maguires-Seafood, 1 Bay Walk Ocean Beach 631-583-8800 **                                                                                                                                                                                                                      

Accessible by boat

Where to eat on Fire Island

Fire Island Ferry – 631-665-3600- 99 Maple Ave Bay Shore NY 11706

LIRR- Montauk Branch- Park Ave & Oak Street Bay Shore NY 11706

Tommy’s Taxi – 631-665-4800- 88 Park Ave Bay Shore NY 11706

Fire Island Water Taxi- 631-665-8885- 99 Maple Ave Bay Shore NY 11706

McArthur Airport – 12 miles from the marina located in Ronkonkoma NY 11779

bottom of page